TheToyZone is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more!

14 Best Stocking Stuffers for Toddlers

Updated 18 November 2020

This post may contain affiliate links.

Author avatar Daniel Booth

Daniel is our primary content producer here at TheToyZone. He is a big kid at heart and a self confessed geek. His mission is to find toys that kids will treasure, researching and writing about toys he wants to play with himself.

On Christmas morning, after you’ve cleared up the snowy footprints from the fireplace, it’s time to open the presents. Leaving stockings out traditionally started so St. Nicholas could leave gold if you were good and coal if you were bad. Nowadays, it’s a fun way to leave mini presents for each other. But what do toddlers in 2020 want to find in their stockings?

We combed through recommendations from real people and checked for any fake reviews to find the 14 best stocking stuffers for toddlers in 2020. As toddlers have different interests, we made sure that our list covers a variety of toys, games, and candy so you can find the perfect stocking stuffers which will add some extra fun to Christmas day.

1Bag Of Reindeer Farts (Best Budget Option)

Bag Of Reindeer Farts (Best Budget Option)

This is an entertaining stocking stuffer that is also delicious! It is full of cotton candy that tastes like peppermint. Toddlers and kids of all ages will enjoy this stocking stuffer, and you can get a laugh out of watching them open it, making it one of the best stocking stuffers for toddlers!

What we love

  • The cotton candy tastes delicious
  • Comes in a hilarious package for enjoyment

We dont like this as much

  • Only comes with peppermint cotton candy flavor

2Play-Doh (Best Eco-Friendly Option)

Play-Doh (Best Eco-Friendly Option)

This is one of the best stocking stuffers for toddlers because it comes with 15 one-ounce cans of Play-Doh that will allow toddlers to create various objects. Each can is a different color, and it can be distributed amongst one stocking or several.

What we love

  • Comes with 15 different colored individual cans
  • Non-toxic and safe for toddlers

We dont like this as much

  • Toddlers may need supervision to avoid making a mess

3Fishing Floating Squirts Toy and Water Scoop

Fishing Floating Squirts Toy and Water Scoop

This will make an excellent stocking stuffer for kids that enjoy playing in water or fishing. It comes with a fishing rod, a fishing net, and five different toys. They can be used inside the bathtub during the holiday season or out in a swimming pool when the weather warms up.

What we love

  • Designed for toddlers 18-months and older
  • Comes with an organizer bag

We dont like this as much

  • The fishing rod doesn't actually reel in the fish

4Nickelodeon Spongebob Finger Puppets

Nickelodeon Spongebob Finger Puppets

These finger puppets are excellent stocking stuffers that are designed to look like the main characters from Nickelodeon’s Spongebob. Each one is made from high-quality material, with a different character for each finger on a single hand.

What we love

  • Have soft rubber openings to fit smaller fingers
  • Designed to promote creative play situations

We dont like this as much

  • Each pack only includes five characters, which only covers one full hand

5Jingle Bells: Christmas Sound Book

Jingle Bells: Christmas Sound Book

This Christmas book is designed to give kids a fun way to enjoy Christmas and the Jingle Bells song. It comes with three different interactive sound buttons, and it has beautiful illustrations for them to look at. Plus, it uses a large font for toddlers that are just starting to learn their alphabet and how to read.

What we love

  • Provides an interactive reading experience
  • Has excellent Christmas illustrations

We dont like this as much

  • It only has three interactive buttons

6Scentco Water Magic - Reusable Water Reveal Activity Books

Scentco Water Magic - Reusable Water Reveal Activity Books

This is a reusable activity book that kids can enjoy when opening their Christmas stockings. It comes with a magical water reveal pen that comes in two pleasant scents: gingerbread, and candy cane. The book includes several pages that include different types of activities to keep toddlers entertained.

What we love

  • Scented pen’s scents are surprisingly accurate
  • Can be used over and over again

We dont like this as much

  • You have to choose which scent prior to purchasing the book

7Cotton Christmas Pajama Set

Cotton Christmas Pajama Set

With these pajamas, toddlers can wake up and enjoy opening their stockings on Christmas Eve or Christmas Day, and be dressed right for the occasion. They are made from warm material, and they are easy to keep clean because they can be machine washed and dried.

What we love

  • Made from high-quality cotton material
  • Pajama set is a three-piece

We dont like this as much

  • They are designed to be long

8The Santa Claus Game

The Santa Claus Game

This board game is an excellent stocking stuffer because it will allow toddlers to play as Santa in an interesting fashion. It is designed to be educational, and it doesn’t take a long time to play through the game. Plus, it has a well-illustrated game board and game accessories as well.

What we love

  • Only takes 15 to 20 minutes to play
  • Can be fun for the entire family

We dont like this as much

  • Has to have at least two people to play

9Holiday-Themed Lollipops

Holiday-Themed Lollipops

These lollipops are delicious treats that toddlers can find in their stockings. The set comes with 12 different lollipops that are designed with various Christmas figures and objects. They come in different flavors and can all be fit into a single stocking or spread between various stockings.

What we love

  • Each lollipop is individually wrapped
  • Not too big and not too small; the perfect sized for a quick treat

We dont like this as much

  • You can't choose which lollipops you get in the pack

10DUPLO Construction Bulldozer 10930

DUPLO Construction Bulldozer 10930

This LEGO Duplo set is perfect for a stocking stuffer because it is small and will provide them with an early Christmas bit of fun to put together. It is designed to help with various developmental skills, and it includes the bulldozer and a figurine that helps to promote creative play for toddlers.

What we love

  • Includes 10 pieces
  • Easy for kids to assemble and build

We dont like this as much

  • It can be combined with other LEGO Duplo sets, but they are sold separately

11MULLSAN Children's Fireplace Lovely Sweater

MULLSAN Children's Fireplace Lovely Sweater

This Christmas sweater is beautiful and made from high-quality material. It can be purchased in three different colors, and they come in different sizes to fit most toddlers. It is excellent for kids that enjoy wearing Christmas-themed clothes and want something to help keep them warm.

What we love

  • Easy to clean
  • Made from high-quality cotton material with an internal fleece fabric for warmth

We dont like this as much

  • It will experience some shrinking if machine dried

12Melissa & Doug Disney Princess Wooden Stamp Set

Melissa & Doug Disney Princess Wooden Stamp Set

For any toddler that enjoys Disney princesses and art, this will make an excellent stocking stuffer for them. It includes 2-color ink pads, nine different stamps, and five colored pencils to enjoy. Plus, it comes in a storage box made from high-quality wood to help keep all of the stamps and accessories organized and together when not being used.

What we love

  • Each stamp features a different Disney-themed princess
  • Comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee

We dont like this as much

  • It only comes with two different colored ink pads

13Little Blue Truck's Christmas

Little Blue Truck's Christmas

This is a beautifully illustrated book that is perfect for toddlers. It is fun and easy to read the story, and it comes with a hardcover to make it more durable for toddlers to fumble through on their own.

What we love

  • Has an easy-to-follow storyline
  • Uses a large font for toddlers to get more familiar with their alphabet

We dont like this as much

  • It only comes in hardcover and kindle format

14Scavenger Hunt Cards

Scavenger Hunt Cards

Scavenger hunts can be fun for the entire family, and this card game is interactive and easy for toddlers to follow and flip through. The game can be played by toddlers 2-years-old and up, and the cards come on a thick plastic ring to keep them all together.

What we love

  • Comes with 20 double-sided cards
  • Small enough to easily fit inside a Christmas stocking

We dont like this as much

  • There are different card packs, but they are sold separately